Most of the broadcasters and journalists are saying that Carlos Marmol should be the Cubs’ closer next year, because he was almost unhittable this year. I disagree.
A closer tends to come in in the 9th inning to save the game. He just has to get through one inning, and you have some room for error. Marmol’s previous role was to come in prior to the 9th inning when there were runners on base and the game was on the line. There is no room for error in these situations, as if you give up a hit, the game is tied or the lead is lost. You have to be almost perfect in these game-on-the-line situations. Coming in in the 9th inning, you do have room for error, as you can give up one or even two hits (or walks) and still get out of the inning.
It is my opinion that it is more important to have Marmol pitch when the game is on the line and you have to stop the other team from scoring. If a pitcher fails in that situation, the game might not get to your closer.